Apple is not perfect, and I know it. I’m not trying to be a Fanboy, even if some people have a hard time distinguishing between Fanboys and and people who like things that are well-designed. No real ordering for my criticism:

Podcasts

Apple supports these, and the built-in support in the iPhone is better than any other app in the AppStore out there as far as I can tell. But I’d still like it to be better. I want to be able to subscribe to podcasts and have them download in the background when there’s WiFi. This feature is clearly missing (and please don’t tell me to 24/7 run my computer for this). Why do I have to do that manually?

 photo credit: eriwst

iCloud lock-in

Steve Jobs said that iCloud’s purpose is to lock people into Apple’s ecosystem. This is not the best for the consumer, unless to turn the argument around and say it’s better for the customers to go with Apple’s products only. Apple, open up an API for external software.

Windows compatibility

Another lock-in argument is that other times, the compatibility with computers running Windows is not great. For example, if I connect to the computer of my girlfriend, copying files is kinda slow and using her printer doesn’t work instantly (which differs to using some networked printer).

Window Borders in Lion

Yay, we can now drag windows on every side to with the mouse pointer to make them bigger or smaller! Sadly, most of the OSX windows were not programmed with this in mind and have zero pixels of borders. This means while I drag the pointer over the border a very short time the icon changes and I can grab the border, but often times I don’t hit this time-window. Apple, how about adding 1px of border on the outside of the window when I hover in it’s direct surrounding, so I at least have a change of grabbing it?

AppStore

The AppStore is your only hope to make money on Apples platforms as a developer. So, if you don’t get featured, you’re most likely lost. This is a lot of power on Apples side, and it should be more obvious how to get featured in the app store other than to make great apps that Apple’s employees like. You should also get more statistical data about the usage of the AppStore, so you don’t have your marketing guys spam keywords all over the place.

AppStore Search

It would also nice, if the Appstore would rank abandon-ware and very poor software lower in searches if was was a) seldomly downloaded b) poorly rated or c) not updated for a very long time. Maybe it should even forget thing that are too bad.

Network connections in Hotels or Academic Networks

Oftentimes, I connect to Hotel networks, free WiFi networks or networks in academic institutions and it just works. About 50% of the time, it doesn’t work and there’s a lot of fiddling with network specific settings involved before I get it to run. How about making this better, as usually Windows is king here.

Next generation programming language

Apple sticks with its old programming language Objective-C without having a contender for the next decade. For example, C# with .NET 4.0 is such an advanced language, that I barely have the heart to compare them. Please don’t comment this. I know you know better than me, but Apple has no solution for stronger machines other than making the devices more competitive by making them smaller.

Contracts

The iOS ecosystem is pretty locked down, with apps having only hacks to communicate to each other. How about stealing contracts from Windows Phone and Windows 8?

Sandboxing

That being said, Sandboxing is pretty bad for app developers if you forgot some entitlements that are necessary to run the software.

Preview

Preview doesn’t always work very good if the PDF is very big. Why, Apple?

Ergonomics vs. Looks

When there’s a design decision between the looks and the ergonomics of an Apple product, the looks win out (explained by John Siracusa on Hypercritical). Apple, please give us bigger arrow keys and better mice! (And Samsung, please don’t copy the questionable design-decisions from Apple!)

iChat / Messages / Twitter

Why is Twitter not integrated into Messages? Why is iChat not integrated with the iOS messages?

Conclusion

Apple is not perfect, and this is what I criticize. I’ll try to fill this list with more that I don’t like about Apple stuff, and remove things that get better. If you have comments, please leave out the price debate, as copying companies like Samsung show that the hardware in Apple-quality cannot be done cheaper.

Related Posts:

• Marketshare and Winning and Religion
• The “Move The Content” Paradigm, Criticism And The Future Of Mac OSX
• Firefox on Mac – Tabs Closed after Restart
• From PC to Mac Book Air 11”
• iOS5 iMessage must be the messaging solution

As I had this effect once before and it went away magically all by itself, I thought of just waiting a bit. One hour later when I was at work, everything worked normal again. Maybe it has some connection to heat, humidity of the air, particles between moving parts that had released themselves on the ride by bike that I do when I go to work. So, if you’re having this problem, my advice is waiting a bit, and retrying over a full day till sending it back.

photo credit: JD Hancock

Related Posts:

• The Big Anti-Apple Rant
• Everybody loves iPhone Bashing
• “Special” iPhone background: Bug, Joke or Malware?
• Marketshare and Winning and Religion
• Objective C Pitfalls for Java and C# Programmers

I never had this opinion. I would always look at how easy an operating system lets me fulfill the tasks I need to fulfill, including the initial learning curve, therefore I chose Windows on computers and iPhone on smartphones. I hate having to configure stuff all the time. I hate how the Android OS makes me click on way too small buttons and phone makers try to combat this with bigger screen sizes. I hate when I have to make way more clicks or text input to get anything done. And I really don’t like when the web browser stutters or I doubletap on a paragraph and it zooms to the sidebar. All pretty small things (yeah, rewriting the UI elements isn’t really a small thing), but if this were different, I’d definitely chose Android. And if Windows Phone gets more powerful and easier to use than iPhone, I’ll choose that one. I really don’t care about religion. And I never advised anyone to pick an iPhone “because everyone does” or “because it won”, and this is my only plea in this whole post: when you’re advocating for Android, please don’t mention that more copies were sold, as this has nothing to do with the quality of the hard- and software.

photo credit: kevindooley

As this post might have religious comments, here’s a disclaimer: I like iPhone best among smartphones, so in your opinion I’m a fanboy – no need to mention that again. I also love customization in my phone from time to time, so I’m jailbreaking – but I also didn’t miss it much when there wasn’t a good jailbreak available. And for the pricing: since here in germany the T-mobile monopoly fell, iPhone is not too pricy anymore – so leave me alone with “I can’t pay for it” – if you can pay 500€ in two years, you can also afford 600€.

Related Posts:

• The Big Anti-Apple Rant
• ToDo for Mac – Review
• Firefox on Mac – Tabs Closed after Restart
• From PC to Mac Book Air 11”
• Stop mocking Microsoft and Nokia

• Pointers and the asterisk: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1105815/placement-of-the-asterisk-in-objective-c
• The type “id” is always a pointer, so no asterisk there
• Strange effects happen when you “#inport” .h files with cyclical references. I didn’t find a better solution than having id instead of the Type I wanted to use in one of my classes
• There are no null pointer exceptions. This means you’ll all the time miss the initialization of some object or some reference and won’t recognize it. Since recognizing this, I love null pointers exceptions. But this is language design in Objective C. So if you definitely need to be sure, throw an exception if you want to be sure and / or add some unit tests.
• When the application crashes, you won’t get meaningful answers from the console often times. To get some more information you’ll need to set a breakpoint in the last thrown exception statement. You can find out more here.
• When you want to use a simple integer like 5 and get the warning / error “makes Pointer from integer without a cast”, you need to use [NSNumber numberFromInt:5]
• Always correct header file first, implemetation file second and always correct from top to bottom, as the compiler does this too. When the compiler sees an error in the header file for example, it might make up 50 more errors somewhere below. This is literally top-down debugging.
• Don’t try to mess with XML too much yourself. Use this nice, free and fast XML framework instead.
• There are great resources for iOS development out there, for example the full open source Canabalt game or framework-like libraries that could make some things easier, if you see it before you’ve implemented all such things yourself.
• To find such resources, I’d read this blog and follow it’s writer on Twitter.
• Oh yeah, and Google and Stackoverflow should fix the rest.

photo credit: Stéfan

Related Posts:

• First time MacOSX, Xcode, Objective C – Random thoughts
• The Big Anti-Apple Rant
• Accepting New Stuff Before Learning It
• Filtering Information & New Idea for Twitter.com
• iPhone Home Button Doesn’t Work?

Microsoft has the people and the brains to maintain a really good mobile OS. In fact, most people whining about WinPhone7 have never seen it or are just anti-Microsoft anyways. WinPhone7 but it has a nice concept and a real nice language and framework for developers. And they don’t feature-overload it like Google does with Android – instead they’re aiming for constistency and a polished OS.

Nokia has the resources to cheaply produce high quality phones and the infrastructure to sell them anywhere in the world. And let’s face it: Microsoft doesn’t produce phones, so it’s nothing new that they’d love to have Nokias with WinOS anyways. The only new thing in this news is that Nokia learned from it’s failure to create a good mobile OS and gives up on that.

Final point: who of you doesn’t love a third competitor besides Android and iOS?

Related Posts:

• Marketshare and Winning and Religion
• Nokia and Microsoft – What they gain from this
• The Big Anti-Apple Rant
• Google “Do a barrel roll”
• Microsoft’s Vision of the Future is not Science Fiction

iPhone		34.3%	(839)
Android		30.4%	(744)
Blackberry		6.9%	(168)
Other Smart Phone		15.0%	(366)
Regular Mobile Phone		25.5%	(624)

The people who answered this survey are pretty smart, they’re all developers who we can agree on being relatively smart. They also all would be able to use and understand complex technology, so features will trump usability in this audience more than in ordinary comsumers. The developers also have pretty good paychecks, so most likely they all can afford all types of smartphones. The list above is not mutually exclusive, so a developer might have an Android, an iPhone and a blackberry device, but added up all percentages are 112,1 … so most likely only ~10% would have two phones.

36.9% are from north america (just to include this AT&T miserablility factor). 7.5% are engaging in mobile development, while many many developers are into web development (from the comments on the stackoverflow post you can see that people were not so sure about this question). Sidenotes:16.1% also have an iPad, 14,4% have a kindle (only 1,6% Nook), 4,7% own an Apple TV. I can’t see any other values play into this, the Java vs. C language proficiency seems pretty equal (they didn’t ask for Objective-C so you can’t draw conclusions from that), well maybe the developers most used operating system is interesting:

Linux		18.2%	(472)
Mac OS X		15.6%	(405)
Windows 7		44.7%	(1,158)
Windows XP		18.3%	(473)
Windows Vista		3.2%	(82)

Is there an iTunes for Linux? From what a quick google search could tell me there isn’t … So are there 18.2% not willing to use an iPhone for that reason?

The only thing I want to add to these numbers is that I would have thought that among developers Android is more common than the iPhone, especially as developers often want to fiddle with the system more. I drew my own conclusions, but as I don’t want to sound like a fanboy again, I just will let you draw your own.

photo credit: Veronica Belmont

Related Posts:

• Marketshare and Winning and Religion
• All the little things & This year of my life
• Nokia 5800 Xpress Music VS iPhone
• The Big Anti-Apple Rant
• ToDo for Mac – Review

• + There’s the possibility to create a WLAN. Yay!
• + Looking at the 2 year costs, it was about 30% cheaper, which is nice.
• - Scrolling is much more unfluid. Makes reading on the web when scrolling is involved much more of a hassle.
• - The browser loading times were not that good.
• - There is no anti-smudge-screen. This actually makes a big difference.
• - Sometimes reactions on pinching is stuttery or just too late.
• - I never know which button I need to press if I want to get back.
• - The camera sucked. The flash is much too bright and the pictures look like crap. To make a shot you needed to press the trackball.
• - I didn’t understand the structure of the applications list vs. the widget screens. I guess the organisation was strange because my father made it so, but why are those two separated?
• - The phone got very hot while just browsing and using google maps.
• - The icons of the applications sucked.
• - The few applications I launched looked kind of “not ready to deliver”.

photo credit: Jesus Belzunce

Related Posts:

• Marketshare and Winning and Religion
• Notification Addiction
• iPhone 4 Feels Great
• The Big Anti-Apple Rant
• iPhone Home Button Doesn’t Work?